Northwest New York Dairy, Livestock & Field Crops Enrollment

Program Areas

  • Dairy Management
  • Farm Business Management
  • Field Crops
  • Livestock & Small Farms

Enrollment Benefits

  • Telephone / Email Consultations
  • Ag Focus Newsletter
  • Direct Mailings
  • Educational Meetings & Conferences
  • In-Field Educational Opportunities
  • On-Farm Research Trials

Enrollee Login

Password:

Log In To Access:

  • Issues of Ag Focus Newsletters
  • Helpful Diagnostic Tool:
      What's wrong with my crop?

Economics of Tile Plow Investment and Use

John Hanchar, Farm Business Management
Northwest New York Dairy, Livestock & Field Crops

July 8, 2013

In an article of the February 2011 issue of AgFocus, James Kingston reviewed the topic of tractor-drawn tile plows. The article utilized data from presentations that he made at the NWNY Dairy, Livestock, and Field Crops Program's 2011 Corn Congresses in January. In the article, James included a brief summary of some economic analyses that we developed to examine tile plow investment and use. The purpose of this article is to provide more detailed information from those economic analyses. For the detailed analyses, including the MS Excel Spreadsheet developed to examine tile investment and use, please visit the team's website at www.nwnyteam.org and click on "AgFocus."
SummaryPartial budget analyses for profit indicated that 16 of the 20 expected feet installed annually, expected tile contractor charge combinations yielded expected increases to profit (Table 1). Net present value analyses indicated that of 14 of the 20 expected feet installed annually, expected tile contractor charge combinations yielded net present values greater than 0. Net present values greater than or equal to 0 reflect capital investments that would be considered attractive to the producer (Table 2).
Refer to Table 1 below
Overall, analyses suggest that if a producer can expect to install about 16,000 feet of tile or more annually over 5 years, then investment and use of a tractor pulled tile plow is attractive given expected contractor charges of about $0.65 per foot or greater.
Refer to Table 2 below
Tractor Drawn Tile Plows
Considering Costs to the Producer of Realizing Savings in Contractor ChargesA review of information sources prior to developing the economic analyses produced material that enthusiastically described the money that can be made using owned machinery and labor versus hiring a contractor. One example noted $4,000 made in one afternoon ($0.50 per foot excluding tile, the contractor charge avoided, times 8,000 feet installed). Although the savings are notable, the analysis seems to ignore that a farmer would expect to incur additional ownership costs (depreciation, interest, insurance and others) and operating costs (hired labor, machinery repairs and maintenance, fuel, oil and lube expense, and others) associated with tile plow investment and use. The purpose of our analysis was to evaluate the expected benefits and costs associated with tile plow investment and use. An important assumption for all of the analyses described below is that the decision to tile has already been made - expected benefits exceeded expected costs. The only decision remaining is whether to have tile installed by a contractor, or install tile using owned equipment and labor supplied by the farm.
Partial Budget AnalysisA partial budget projects the expected change in profit associated with a proposed change in the farm business, for example, investment in and use of a tile plow compared to hiring a contractor. The expected change in profit equals the expected change in total value of production, income minus the expected change in the costs of inputs used in production. With regards to tiling, expected cost savings might be considerable. However, what cost increases will the farmer incur to realize these savings? A partial budget considers all expected changes to income and costs ?? the decreases and the increases.<br><br>Net 
Present Value AnalysisNet present value analysis considers the time value of a stream of net cash flows, income over the life of the investment. The time value of money concept results from the fact that individuals, when given the choice, would prefer to receive a dollar today over a dollar received at some future date, for example, a year from now. The net present value of an investment is the sum of the present values for each year's net cash flow less the initial cost of the investment. If the net present value of an investment is greater than or equal to zero, then the investment is attractive to the decision maker. For this analysis, the initial cost of the investment was $33,000 for the tile plow, stringer cart, and control system.
The analyses described here focused on expected changes in profit and net present values of the investment. James' February article mentioned other considerations that help to determine whether tile plow investment and use makes sense for an individual operation.


Economics of Tile Plow Table 1 & 2 (pdf; 185KB)


Dairy

Dairy

Livestock

Livestock

Grazing

Grazing

Forages

Forages

Grains

Grains

calendar of events

Upcoming Events

2019 Corn Silage Pre-Harvest Workshop - Penn Yan

September 17, 2019
10:00am to Noon
Penn Yan, NY

Corn silage harvest is drawing near. The way corn silage is harvested and stored is a single event that affects your operation for the entire next year. Are you prepared to set your operation up for success? 
view details

Ontario County Fun on the Farm

September 21, 2019
11:00 am- 4:00 pm
Seneca Castle, NY

Fun on the Farm works to educate non-farm public and our neighbors about agriculture around them. It is fun and educational.

Fun on the Farm attracts thousands of people and gives us the opportunity to communicate to the community the benefits of the agricultural production in Ontario County, the state, and the nation.

The event is free! There are many agricultural products that are available to be sampled. It is the perfect place to try that product you have seen in the store but didn't want to commit to purchasing.

Food is available to purchase for lunch. It is provided by a local service group.
view details

Bovine Reproduction and AI Training Course

September 24 - September 25, 2019
9:30am - 3:30pm
Shortsville, NY

**CLASS IS FULL**

This two-day AI workshop will be held on September 24 and 25. 

Topics covered will include:

• Reproductive Physiology
• Synchronization Protocols
• Heat Detection
• Artificial Insemination
• Proper Thawing of Semen
• Loading A.I. guns
• Practice Breeding Cows

view details

Announcements

Preventing Sexual Harassment on Farms

If you're wondering how to get your farm business in compliance with NYS Sexual Harassment Regulations, you've come to the right place.  The 2018 New York State budget included new regulations addressing sexual harassment in the workplace that became effective on October 9, 2018 for all New York employers, including agricultural employers. All employers are required to have a sexual harassment prevention policy and to provide annual, interactive sexual harassment prevention training for all employees.  Check out the resources developed by Cornell Ag Workforce Development, including step-by-step instructions and farm-friendly training videos.


RMA Announces Additional One-time Changes to Prevented Planting Provisions

June 29, 2019

RMA Announces Additional One-time Changes to Prevented Planting Provisions
for 2019 Crop Year

In response to delayed and prevented planting resulting from above average rainfall and wetness, the USDA Risk Management Agency has made a one-time change to the 2019 crop year prevented planting rules that effectively allows silage corn, if planted as a cover crop following local agricultural expert guidelines, to be acceptable as a post-prevented planting cover crop. Under this one-time rule change, producers are allowed to produce this crop while retaining their prevented planting payment. This change couples with previously announced one-time changes to the prevented planting rules - including expanded acceptable uses for post-prevented planting cover crops and a change in the cover crop haying and grazing start date rule - serve to help those struggling to meet their forage needs due to the weather.

Read the full article from the New York Crop Insurance Education Program.

The USDA-RMA states that "For crop insurance purposes, a cover crop is a crop generally recognized by agricultural experts as agronomically sound for the area for erosion control or other purposes related to conservation or soil improvement." PRO-DAIRY specialists Joe Lawrence and Karl Czymmek and Dr. Quirine Ketterings, Professor and Director of Cornell Nutrient Management Spear Program have released a letter stating "Corn on Prevented Planting acres meets these objectives."


NEWSLETTER   |   CURRENT PROJECTS   |   IMPACT IN NY   |   SPONSORSHIP  |  RESOURCES   |   SITE MAP